Same ROAS as What?
For the person who has to turn a growth target into a Google Ads plan, on an account that already earns most of its reported return from its own name.
Last verified October 2026
You know this meeting. Brand search carries the account, brand impression share is near full, and the business wants more revenue at the same ROAS. A Google rep has a plan, and the plan promises results at a "similar ROAS." Everyone leaves thinking they've agreed. In an account like this they may have agreed on two different numbers, and nobody finds out until the money is spent.
One consultant described a case close to that on r/PPC in late October. A CPG company's performance came almost entirely from branded traffic, with brand impression share at 95%, and it wanted to expand and keep its "current ROAS targets." The rep's first idea was Demand Gen. The client negotiated "some credit from google" and agreed to a limited campaign if it could "at least pay for itself at 1x roas." It was shut off after $16k and one view-through conversion. The rep's next idea was non-brand AI Max. The client approved it over the consultant's objection, and it was stopped after a few days, having spent $12k and generated $1k.
Most of the replies were about reps. A few did the sum, and QuantumWolf99 put it in one line: "Holding brand ROAS while adding non-brand pulls the total ROAS down." You have probably said that sentence to someone. It's correct, and it rarely ends the conversation, because the person asking hears a no and didn't ask for one. What helps more is knowing what "same ROAS" would buy, in dollars, on your own account, and what it has been letting through.
Two numbers, one phrase
Take a made-up month. Brand impression share is 95%. The margin is 50%, so a dollar of ads needs $2 of revenue to pay for itself on the first order.
If columns extend beyond the page, scroll sideways. With a keyboard, focus the table and use the arrow keys.
| Spend | Revenue | ROAS | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brand | $10,000 | $150,000 | 15.0x |
| Non-brand | $30,000 | $90,000 | 3.0x |
| Account | $40,000 | $240,000 | 6.0x |
A rep proposes $10,000 a month of new non-brand at a similar ROAS, and suppose it does exactly that and returns 3x. The account goes to $50,000 of spend, $270,000 of revenue and 5.4x. The rep's promise was kept. The business makes $5,000 more a month. And the request failed, because the request meant 6.0x, which would have needed that $10,000 to bring back $60,000.
Nobody lied. Google's list of recommendations says "at a similar ROAS" and "at a similar or better ROI" again and again, and it never says similar to what. In context it means the campaign being changed. Nothing there mentions an account's blended number. The person asking means the account. So the first move in this meeting is to ask the question in the title. If the answer is "the campaigns," the account number is going to fall, and everyone should hear that now. If the answer is "the account," the request is stranger than it sounds, and it's worth finding out what it charges.
What the account number charges for a dollar
Start with what brand leaves over. At 6.0x, $10,000 of spend has to bring in $60,000, and brand brings in $150,000. The extra $90,000 of revenue is what lets the rest of the account fall short, so call it the allowance. A non-brand dollar uses the allowance by however much it falls short of 6x: $3 at a 3x return, $6 at no return at all.
That's why today's $30,000 at 3x uses all $90,000. It's also why non-brand could have been only $15,000 in total, all of it returning nothing, and the account would still read 6.0x. Past that point, each added dollar has to bring in $6.
If columns extend beyond the page, scroll sideways. With a keyboard, focus the table and use the arrow keys.
| Non-brand spend | Revenue it must bring to hold 6.0x | Average it must hit |
|---|---|---|
| $15,000 | $0 | 0.0x |
| $18,000 | $18,000 | 1.0x |
| $22,500 | $45,000 | 2.0x |
| $30,000 (today) | $90,000 | 3.0x |
| $40,000 (the rep's plan) | $150,000 | 3.75x |
| $45,000 | $180,000 | 4.0x |
| $90,000 | $450,000 | 5.0x |
Today's spend meets that requirement exactly, which is all that being on target means. Two things in that table should bother you. The bar non-brand must clear rises as the line grows, while what the line actually earns falls: Google's own Demand Gen guide says "Increasing spend exhausts lower-hanging inventory first." And in revenue per dollar of spend, the target only ever quotes two prices. It's $0 while there's allowance left and $6 once there isn't. Break-even, at this margin, is $2.
So "same ROAS" goes wrong in both directions. With the allowance used up, it turns down a 3x dollar that makes money on the first order. With allowance to spare, it passes a dollar that returns nothing. And it can't show you what's already inside the average. Non-brand at 3x could be $23,000 at about 3.8x plus $7,000 at 0.5x, and the account would read 6.0x either way.
Run it on your own account
You need five numbers from one month that has finished reporting conversions: brand spend, brand conversion value, account spend, account conversion value and the target being asked for. For the break-even side you also need your margin, which gave this account its $2. Start with any brand campaigns, then check the search terms report of your other campaigns for terms containing your name, because brand searches can also sit in non-brand campaigns, and add their cost and conversion value to the brand total. Performance Max has its own view in that report's dropdown. Google omits some low-volume terms, so treat the total as a minimum. Non-brand is whatever's left.
If columns extend beyond the page, scroll sideways. With a keyboard, focus the table and use the arrow keys.
| Number | Sum | This account |
|---|---|---|
| Allowance | Brand revenue − target × brand spend | $150,000 − 6 × $10,000 = $90,000 |
| Used by non-brand | Target × non-brand spend − non-brand revenue | 6 × $30,000 − $90,000 = $90,000 |
| Room left | Allowance − used | $0 |
| New spend the room can carry at return r | Room left ÷ (target − r) | $0 at any return under 6.0x |
Once the room is gone, the return a new dollar must clear to hold the number is the target itself. Here that's 6.0x. If your room left is positive, you can carry some new spend below the target until it runs out. With $20,000 of room, that's $20,000 ÷ (6 − 3), or about $6,667 at 3x. If it's negative, the account is already under the number.
The size of the request
An account on its target has no room, so the growth "same ROAS" can buy depends on the room you can make. Removing a dollar that returns 0.5x frees $5.50. A new dollar at 2.5x uses $3.50. So each $1,000 of 0.5x spend you cut pays for about $1,570 at 2.5x.
Say this account finds $7,000 of spend returning 0.5x. Cutting it frees $38,500, which pays for $11,000 of new spend at 2.5x. Revenue loses $3,500 and gains $27,500, so the account grows 10% and still reads 6.0x. That size rests on both returns. If the $7,000 was returning 1.0x, the growth is 7.5%. If it was returning 0.5x but the replacement holds only 2.0x, the growth is about 6.6%.
The place to look for that spend is the search terms report, and our own product, Cascader, runs scans that recommend which terms to block, with a written reason for each.
The replacement is the softer number, because it asks for $11,000 of new spend on a line now at $23,000. To test it, use a target ROAS simulator, whose rows cover seven days, so $11,000 a month is about $2,500 of extra cost. Compare the row nearest your current cost with the row about $2,500 above it, not two neighboring rows, which only price a small step. Divide the extra conversion value by the extra cost, keeping in mind that both are Google's estimates from the last seven days. If no row reaches that far, the simulator can't speak for the full step.
A cut isn't the only source of room. Non-brand pockets already beating 6.0x add to it as they grow, and so does anything that raises what a click is worth, such as conversion rate or basket size. Brand's missing 5% can add a little too, though expecting today's rates there is optimistic: Google counts auctions as within reach that could need twice your current bid. Growth beyond what those supply lowers the account number.
That's a better reply than "utterly impossible," the consultant's word for the request. You can say how much growth the number allows and what that rests on. You can also say that past that point, on reported first-order revenue, a dollar returning between $2 and $6 earns money and lowers the ROAS, and a dollar under $2 doesn't earn its keep. Then ask the person what they want: what's the lowest return you'd accept on a new dollar?
What the number is for
Find out why the 6.0x exists, because it may be doing honest work. At 6.0x, ads cost 16.7% of revenue, and a business with a cash limit or a plan built on that percentage has a real reason to hold it. Sam Tomlinson calls this a fence and says to write it as one sentence: maximize contribution dollars subject to blended ROAS at or above X. If that's what the 6.0x is, keep it, make the room you can, and tell the rep no with a reason.
If it's a belief that every dollar ought to earn 6x, it's a different thing, and Tomlinson's complaint about these targets applies: "virtually no one can derive it." The range from $2 to $6 is then where the conversation belongs.
What the allowance is made of
So far we've trusted the report, and the allowance is the part of it that deserves the least trust. It's brand revenue, which is the revenue most likely to have arrived without the ad. Our review of the brand studies explains why no single percentage comes out of them: much depends on whether the organic listing catches the click and whether a rival would take the slot.
You can still see what the question does here. The allowance is 60% of brand's reported revenue, so if 60% of brand's sales would have happened anyway, the allowance is made entirely of sales the ads didn't cause. Common Thread's Q1 2026 benchmark, using its own holdouts and models across 299 DTC brands, credits Google brand with 30 cents of each reported dollar. At that rate $105,000 of our $150,000 would have come anyway, which is more than the whole allowance. The same benchmark marks non-brand down by a quarter, so this is no case for non-brand, and no reason to pause brand. It means a report showing room isn't evidence the business can afford the spend.
Non-brand's 3x can be wrong in either direction, which is why $2 is where the argument about a floor starts, not where it ends. It can read too low, because non-brand often starts journeys that brand search finishes, and that lowers the floor. It can read too high, because frequent shoppers who'd have bought anyway can make up much of the attributed revenue, as they did at eBay, and that raises it. That's why a commenter's advice in the thread is sound, to judge non-brand on new customers.
The allowance can also shrink for reasons that have nothing to do with non-brand. Say a rival arrives and brand costs double for the same revenue. The allowance falls from $90,000 to $30,000 and the account reads 4.8x. Since $30,000 covers only $10,000 of spend at 3x, holding 6.0x would mean cutting non-brand by two-thirds. A competitor bids on your name and the target's response is to retreat from everyone who hasn't heard of you.
The plan on the table
Restate the plan in dollars before anyone discusses campaign types. The rep's $10,000 has to bring $60,000 to hold the account and $20,000 to break even on the first order. Ask which of those the forecast claims. Then give the line its own number before money moves. QuantumWolf99's rule is a "Budget cap, success metric, and a kill date, signed off by whoever approves spend," and another commenter asks reps to email the reason: "why this campaign type for this account."
If the plan is Demand Gen, there's a fair case for it that the consultant's post never tests. Brand impression share is already near full, so that line grows when more people search for the name, and that effect wouldn't show in the campaign's own ROAS. That doesn't exempt it from a floor. We'd count the sales a controlled comparison shows the plan caused, whichever campaign gets the credit, and hold that return to the same floor as any new dollar.
That comparison often runs through the seller. A lift study compares people or regions shown the ads with those that weren't, and Google's geographic version of Conversion Lift is meant for total, unattributed return. You arrange it with a Google account representative, and it isn't available to every account, so "this account isn't eligible" can be a true answer. That doesn't end the question, because a comparison of your own counts too: run the plan in some regions and not others, with the two sets comparable or randomly chosen, and compare the change in total sales against the gap already between them.
Search Lift shows whether searches for your brand rose, but a lift in searches isn't a lift in sales, and we wouldn't put a dollar value on one. The only rate to hand is brand's reported one, the figure we've just said to trust least. Don't accept a Branded searches count in place of that comparison. That metric counts searches after people viewed an ad, including people who'd have searched anyway.
Nothing can read the sales when Google's studies are out of reach and your own comparison can't work, either because you can't see sales by region or because the plan is too small to stand out from normal swings in sales. Then the plan hasn't cleared the floor. Either someone signs for it as a capped bet with an end date, or you pass.
What the client got right
That client got something right that's easy to miss. Before the Demand Gen money moved, it gave the new line its own number, separate from the account's, which is what the thread's best replies went on to recommend. The number was too low: at any margin below 100%, 1x leaves the goods unpaid for, and the post doesn't say how the credit figured in it. For the AI Max campaign the post reports no number at all, and that one went through $12k in days.
Even a 6.0x chosen for good reason is a limit on the account, and it can't say what a new dollar has to return. It quotes $0 until the allowance runs out and $6 after. At this margin, a dollar stops paying for itself on the first order below $2. The lowest return you'll accept on a new dollar is the number someone has to choose and defend, and we'd rather walk into that meeting with a wrong one written down than with "same ROAS," because a wrong number can be pointed at.